Confusing the year you are taxed on with the year you are filing. Two tax years are live at once and they carry different numbers. The rates on this page are 2026/27, in force from 6 April 2026 — they are what your current trading year will be taxed at. The return most people are filling in between now and 31 January 2027 is for 2025/26, which ended on 5 April 2026 and is taxed on that year's rates. Use this calculator to plan and to size what to set aside; take the figure you actually pay this January from your 2025/26 return itself.
Running combined income through the Class 4 thresholds. Class 4 National Insurance is charged on self-employment profit alone, never on profit plus a salary. Nia in the examples above has £46,000 of combined income and pays £0.00 of Class 4. Feeding the combined figure into the formula instead produces £2,005.80 — a confident, precise, entirely fictional number. The rule is asymmetric and that is what makes it easy to get wrong: income tax stacks the two sources together, National Insurance keeps them apart.
Budgeting from the bill instead of from the January total. The tax due on a year's profit and the cash that leaves your account in January are different numbers, and the second one is the one that bounces a direct debit. On £45,000 of profit the bill is 18.7% of profit but the first January costs 28.1% of it. Traders who put aside a fifth of everything they earn are usually right about the tax and short by half of one payment on account. The card above marked "what leaves your bank" is the figure to budget against.
The £1,000 allowance is tested on turnover, the tax thresholds on profit. These are different measures and mixing them up produces both false alarms and missed deadlines. Gross trading income above £1,000 means you must register for Self Assessment and file, even if the allowance wipes the profit out and no tax is due. The £12,570 and £12,570 thresholds, by contrast, test profit after the deduction. Sam above has £80.00 of tax to pay and still has to file a return. The allowance also cannot create a loss: claimed against £400 of turnover it deducts £400, not £1,000.
The band table says 40% where the real marginal rate is 62%. Between £100,000 and £125,140 of income, each extra pound of profit is taxed at 40% and simultaneously strips 50p of Personal Allowance that was itself sheltering income from 40% tax. That is 60% of income tax, plus 2% of Class 4 — the steepest stretch of the whole UK curve, and it appears in no published rate table because it is an interaction rather than a rate. This calculator measures the marginal rate by finite difference rather than looking it up, which is why the figure it shows in that band is not one of the numbers on the government's own page.
Assuming a payment on account covers your student loan. It does not. gov.uk puts student loans and capital gains in the balancing payment: it "will also include anything you owe for capital gains or student loans (if you're self-employed)". Payments on account are described as covering your tax bill "including Class 4 National Insurance", and this calculator follows that split exactly — the instalments are half of income tax plus Class 4, while any student loan repayment is billed in full each January. The practical effect is that a borrower's January total is not a neat multiple of their annual bill, and the more of the bill is student loan, the further from 150% it sits.
Expecting Class 4 to stop the moment you reach State Pension age. It stops later than almost everyone assumes. gov.uk's rule is that you stop paying Class 4 from 6 April — the start of the tax year — after you reach State Pension age, so the entire tax year in which you turn 66 remains fully chargeable, including the months after your birthday. Class 1 for employees stops immediately on reaching pension age, which is where the confusion comes from: the two contribution classes behave differently on the same event, and only one of them waits for the new tax year.
Watching the £90,000 VAT line annually instead of on a rolling basis. VAT registration is compulsory once taxable turnover for any rolling 12 months exceeds £90,000 — not once a tax year or an accounting year does. A trader watching only the year to 5 April can cross the line in, say, the twelve months to 30 November and not notice. You then have 30 days from the end of that month to register, and registration takes effect from the first day of the second month after you went over, so late registration means owing VAT on sales you charged no VAT on.